Skip to content

Crypto tax service

Koinly and Recap tax reports, checked against UK rules.

Is your Koinly or Recap report right for UK tax? It can be, but only if the settings, the imports and the labels are all right too, and a wrong report still looks finished. UK individuals hold each type of token in a section 104 pool at average cost, match buys on the same day as a sale, and in the 30 days after it, before they touch the pool, and leave moves between their own wallets out of the gains altogether. A report run on FIFO, LIFO or specific identification gives a different figure. HMRC itself says the reports exchanges give you "are not tax calculations" and "will not keep track of your pooled costs", and that's why people turn to software in the first place. We take your export, check the method, the matching, the transfers and the DeFi entries, and hand back a crypto reconciliation you can file or disclose from.

s104
One pool per type of token, at average cost: the method UK individuals use (CRYPTO22200)
30 days
Buys in the 30 days after a sale are matched to it, earliest sale first, before the pool
NFTs
Not pooled: each NFT keeps its own cost, and no matching rules apply

What to check in a Koinly or Recap report, and what UK rules need

We check each of these on every report we review. Get one wrong and that year's gain moves.

What to check in a Koinly or Recap report, and what UK rules need
CheckWhat to look for in your reportWhat UK rules need
Cost basis methodWhether the settings use FIFO, LIFO, specific identification or average costOne section 104 pool per type of token, at average cost
Buys on the day of a saleWhether a same-day buy is matched to that saleMatched first (TCGA 1992 s105)
Buys in the 30 days after a saleWhether those buys are matched back to the saleMatched next, earliest sale first, before the pool (TCGA 1992 s106A)
Moves between your own walletsWhether transfers between your own wallets and exchanges show up as salesNot a disposal, because you still own the tokens (CRYPTO22100)
Missing costs and odd balancesSales with no cost, or balances that don't match the exchangeEvery sale needs its real cost, so the missing history has to be found, not set to zero
DeFi deposits and pool entriesHow lending deposits and liquidity-pool entries are labelled2026/27: HMRC's current view, under which many count as disposals (CRYPTO61000). From 6 April 2027: no gain, no loss for individuals and trustees, announced but not yet law
NFTsWhether NFTs have been put into a poolNot pooled: each NFT keeps its own cost, and no matching rules apply
These are the rules for individuals. Companies pay Corporation Tax on crypto, under different rules. Source: HMRC Cryptoassets Manual CRYPTO22200.

The challenges clients face.

01

FIFO and specific identification give the wrong UK figure

Section 104 pooling puts every buy of a token into one pool, and each sale takes its cost at the pool's average at that moment. FIFO takes the cost of your earliest coins instead, and specific identification lets you pick which coins you sold. Neither is how UK rules cost a fungible token, so a report set to either can be out in both directions, and the error builds up over the years. So if you've gone looking for a calculator that costs each coin by specific identification, that's the wrong setting for a UK return.

02

Same-day and 30-day matching needs your whole history, in order

Under HMRC's matching rules, a sale is matched first with buys of the same token on the same day (TCGA 1992 s105), then with buys in the next 30 days, earliest sale first (s106A), and only then with the pool. Software can only match what it can see. If an exchange is missing, or a buy carries the wrong date, the matching shifts and that year's gain or loss moves with it. And if you trade the same token every few days, plenty of your sales will land inside those windows.

03

Moving coins between your own wallets isn't a disposal, but a report can count it as one

Moving tokens between wallets and exchanges you own isn't a disposal, because you keep beneficial ownership throughout. Swapping one token for another, or sending tokens to someone else, is. Traded on several exchanges? Then every transfer between them has to be paired, the withdrawal on one with the deposit on the other. An unpaired transfer can show up as a sale on one side and a buy with no cost on the other, which inflates the gain. So if your report flags missing cost basis, or balances that don't match your exchange, check the transfers first.

04

DeFi deposits and pool entries can be disposals now, with a change announced for April 2027

For 2026/27, HMRC's current view still applies: many moves into lending protocols and liquidity pools count as disposals now, where you stop owning the tokens. A report that treats every DeFi deposit as a neutral transfer can understate the gain. From 6 April 2027 the government plans to treat lending tokens and adding them to a liquidity pool as no gain, no loss, so tax waits until you actually dispose of them (announced in July 2026 and confirmed at the Budget on 28 October 2026, still to pass in the Finance Bill). Until then, we label each DeFi entry by what the protocol actually does with your tokens.

How we help.

01

We check the method and rebuild the pools

We start with your export and your settings. If any period ran on FIFO, LIFO or specific identification, we rebuild each token's pool at average cost in date order, so every sale carries the right allowable cost. Where the fix can be made in the software's own settings, we'll tell you which ones; where it can't, we make the correction ourselves and show it.

02

We apply the matching rules and pair up your transfers

We go through every sale with a buy of the same token on the same day or in the 30 days after, and match them in HMRC's order. Our worked example of the same-day and 30-day rules shows those steps with real numbers. We also pair the transfers between your own wallets and exchanges, find the missing history behind any balance that doesn't add up, and check every DeFi entry. Our reconciliation report then lists which sales were matched, against which buys, and what changed from the software's figure.

03

A reconciled report you can file or disclose from

The reconciled figures go into your Self Assessment SA108 filing or, where earlier years are wrong, into a voluntary disclosure through HMRC's cryptoasset service. Anything still uncertain, such as a DeFi position or records an exchange no longer holds, is written up with the method we used, so it's clear how each figure was reached. Just want a ballpark first? The crypto CGT estimator gives one from your total gain, or matches a short list of trades in one token for you.

Common questions

Is Koinly accurate for UK tax?
It can be, if it's set up right, so check three things. First, the cost basis method in your settings: for a UK individual it needs to be s104 pooling at average cost, not FIFO or specific identification. Second, that every exchange and wallet you've used is imported, with your own wallets marked as yours. Third, that the report shows same-day and 30-day matching, not just pool disposals. Software can't flag a gap it can't see, like an exchange you forgot to connect, and catching those is what a UK accountant review is for.
What pooling method should my crypto tax report use in the UK?
Section 104 pooling at average cost, with one pool per type of token. Each sale takes the average cost of everything in that pool at the time. Two things sit outside it: buys matched to a sale under the same-day and 30-day rules, which never enter the pool, and NFTs, which HMRC says aren't pooled because each one is separately identifiable. FIFO, LIFO and specific identification aren't how UK rules cost fungible tokens.
Why does FIFO give the wrong UK answer?
Because it uses the cost of your oldest coins, not the pool's average. Say you bought 100 SOL for £10,000, then another 100 SOL for £16,000, and later sold 100 SOL for £18,000, with no buys on the day of the sale or in the 30 days after. Under s104 pooling the 200 SOL cost £26,000, or £130 each, so the sale's cost is £13,000 and the gain is £5,000. FIFO takes the first £10,000 and reports a gain of £8,000. In a rising market FIFO tends to overstate the gain, and when prices fall it can understate it. Either way, it isn't the UK figure.
What are the same-day and 30-day rules and can software handle them?
A sale is matched first with buys of the same token that day, then with buys in the following 30 days, earliest sale first, and only then with the s104 pool. So selling and buying back within 30 days doesn't reset your cost: the buyback is matched to the sale. Software can apply the rules if it has your complete history in the right order. Recap, for one, says on its own site that it's compliant with HMRC's "bed and breakfast and share pooling rules" (recap.io, as at November 2026). Whether your figure is right still depends on every exchange and wallet making it into the import.
My report shows a large gain from swaps I never cashed out. Is that right?
It can be. Every swap between tokens is a disposal at sterling market value at the time of the swap. If you swapped into a token that then fell, the gain on the swap still counts, even though what you hold now is worth less. But if moves between your own wallets have been labelled as swaps, those aren't disposals, and the report needs fixing.
Can you work from a Recap or CoinTracking export too?
Yes. At Crypto Tax Partners we'll work from a Recap, Koinly or CoinTracking export, or from raw exchange files if that's all you've got. With Recap the review's the same as for any other tool: the pooling method, same-day and 30-day matching, transfers against disposals, and how DeFi entries are treated.
Can you fix a report that was filed on the wrong method in a previous year?
Yes. We rebuild the right figures for each year first. A return can be corrected online within 12 months of the Self Assessment deadline; for older years the usual route is a disclosure through HMRC's cryptoasset disclosure service, and how far back that goes depends on why the figure was wrong. We'll tell you which route fits once we've seen the numbers.

Free consultation

Speak to a crypto tax specialist.

Tell us about your situation and we will come back to you.

Get in touch

Step 1 of 2 · About you

Optional: a bit more detail (helps us prepare)