Trader status is usually a worse outcome, not a prize
Reddit and DIY culture treat trader status as something to pursue, but the numbers run the other way. Trading profits are charged to income tax at up to 45% and attract Class 4 National Insurance, currently 6% on profits between £12,570 and £50,270 and 2% above that. CGT tops out at 24%. Losses are where it can go the other way: a trading loss can be set against your other income, within limits (ITA 2007 s64), while a capital loss only reduces gains. And if it is a trade, the cash basis is now the standard way to work out your profit, and your trading income before costs counts towards Making Tax Digital for Income Tax: over £50,000 in 2024/25 brought quarterly updates from April 2026, and over £30,000 in 2025/26 brings them from April 2027. Not sure which side you're on? The badges of trade checker is a quick first look, and whether HMRC sees you as a trader is the question a status opinion from Crypto Tax Partners settles.