Skip to content

Crypto CGT & Disposals

Lost Crypto, Rug Pulls and Exchange Collapse: When You Can Claim a Tax Loss

9 min read

Losing access to crypto isn't the same as a tax loss. This guide separates the three scenarios, explains what HMRC actually allows, and shows where DIY loss claims tend to go wrong.

You lost crypto. A project collapsed. An exchange froze withdrawals. You've read that you can write the loss off against your tax bill. Sometimes you can, but there are three situations here that are easy to blur, and mixing them up can mean a rejected claim, an enquiry, or a loss that lands in the wrong tax year or doesn't count at all.

HMRC's Cryptoassets Manual answers more of this than you'd expect. Where it stops, the facts decide.

The short answer: it depends, and losing keys is not the same as a worthless token

Whether you can claim a tax loss on lost or inaccessible crypto depends on which of three situations you're in. Losing private keys or access doesn't create a capital loss on its own; only a disposal or a negligible value claim can do that. A negligible value claim works when the tokens are worth next to nothing, or, on HMRC's view, when you can show there's no prospect of ever getting the key or the tokens back. Exchange collapse is a third category: fact-specific, legally uncertain in places, and never a guaranteed deduction. Here are the three side by side.

Scenario Is it a disposal? Is a loss potentially available? How
Lost private keys / forgotten password No Only if there's no prospect of recovery, or the token is also worthless Negligible value claim if you can show the key or tokens can't be recovered (HMRC CRYPTO22400), or the token itself has collapsed; otherwise no loss
Rug pull / dead chain (worthless token) No sale needed Yes, if the asset is genuinely worthless Formal negligible value claim (HMRC CRYPTO22500)
Exchange collapse (FTX-class) Fact-specific Possibly, but no deduction is guaranteed May be negligible value claim, loss on claim against exchange, or nothing yet; professional judgment required

Want this checked against your specific situation?

Leave your details and a one-line summary. A specialist will come back to you, with no obligation.

We'll only use your details to respond to your enquiry. We don't pass them to any other firm. See our Privacy Policy.

Losing private keys: why HMRC does not treat this as a disposal

HMRC's Cryptoassets Manual at CRYPTO22400 is clear that misplacing your private key (its example is throwing away the piece of paper it's printed on) doesn't count as a disposal. The key still exists as part of the cryptography and the tokens still sit on the ledger. No disposal means no CGT event, so losing access doesn't by itself give you a loss. The tokens stay in your section 104 pool at their original cost.

That isn't always the end of it, though. The same page says that if you can show there's no prospect of recovering the private key or accessing the tokens, a negligible value claim could be made. If HMRC accepts it, you're treated as disposing of and reacquiring the tokens you can't access, and that crystallises the loss. The test is the evidence. A password you might still crack, or a seed phrase that could be in a drawer somewhere, won't meet it.

So when keys are lost, there are two routes to a loss: show the key's gone for good, or show the tokens themselves are worth next to nothing. Theft is different again. HMRC doesn't treat it as a disposal, because you still own the stolen tokens and have a right to recover them, and its crypto manual says "victims of theft cannot claim a loss" (CRYPTO22450). Its general gains manual does say a negligible value claim "would be competent" where there's no likelihood of getting a stolen asset back (CG13155), so a theft claim turns on the facts.

Genuinely worthless tokens (rug pulls, dead chains): the negligible value claim

HMRC's Cryptoassets Manual at CRYPTO22500 confirms you can crystallise a loss on tokens you still own if they've become worthless or of negligible value while you owned them. The claim treats the tokens as disposed of and immediately reacquired at the value stated in the claim, which can be nil. Your allowable loss is your allowable cost less that value. Because tokens are pooled, the claim covers your whole section 104 pool of that token, not individual tokens.

You don't need to sell the token for the claim to work. It's the route for assets that have collapsed so far that a market sale is impossible or would realise almost nothing.

Common situations where a negligible value claim may be appropriate:

  • A rug pull where the development team abandoned the project, liquidity was withdrawn, and the token now trades at a fraction of a penny or not at all.
  • A blockchain that has been abandoned, with tokens on it that have no remaining market.
  • A token whose smart contract has been exploited and rendered permanently non-functional.

The claim can be backdated to an earlier point in time, provided you owned the asset then and it was already at negligible value on that earlier date. The backdating is limited: under TCGA 1992 section 24(2) the earlier date can be no more than two years before the start of the tax year in which the claim is made. So a claim made in 2026/27 can be backdated to 6 April 2024 at the earliest. There's no deadline for making the claim itself while you still own the tokens (CG13125). That two-year backdating limit is a different rule from the four-year time limit for claiming a capital loss, and they're easy to mix up.

What counts as "negligible"? The legislation doesn't define it. HMRC takes it to mean "worth next to nothing", so a token that's merely down 80% from its peak won't qualify. Evidence matters: trading history, blockchain explorer data showing abandoned activity, and project communications all help support the claim.

Negligible value vs lost keys: the distinction DIY guides blur

It's easiest to see with one example, changed halfway through.

Say you bought 10,000 units of a small-cap token in 2021 for £5,000. In 2023 the project's developers disappeared and the token's value collapsed to effectively zero. You've also lost access to the wallet holding them, because you no longer have the seed phrase.

You've got two facts here: the token's worthless, and you can't get into the wallet. Either could support a negligible value claim, but the collapse is far easier to prove, because the price history and the abandoned contract are on the public record. Proving a seed phrase is gone for good is much harder. If those 10,000 units are your whole pool and you claim in 2026/27 at nil, you get a £5,000 loss. But the earliest date you can put on it is 6 April 2024, so it can't go back to 2023, when the token actually died.

Now change the scenario. The token still trades at its original value, but you can't access the wallet. Being locked out doesn't give you a loss. You'd only get one through a negligible value claim, by showing there's no prospect of recovering the key or the tokens, and HMRC has to accept it.

Both feel the same, because either way the crypto's gone. HMRC only asks whether there's been a disposal or a valid negligible value claim, and being locked out of a live asset is neither unless you can show it's gone for good.

Exchange collapse (FTX-class): why it is fact-specific and no deduction is promised

When a major exchange freezes withdrawals and goes into administration, the tax position of UK account holders is genuinely uncertain. It depends on facts nobody has at the moment of collapse.

HMRC's pages on lost keys (CRYPTO22400), fraud (CRYPTO22450) and negligible value (CRYPTO22500) point to three possible outcomes, none of them definite at the point of collapse:

  1. Negligible value claim on the tokens held at the exchange. If the tokens themselves have become worthless (for example, the exchange's own token has collapsed), a negligible value claim may be possible, with the same two-year backdating limit. But that depends on the token being worth next to nothing, not merely frozen at the exchange.
  2. Capital loss on the legal claim against the exchange. Account holders in an exchange administration may have a legal claim (a debt or trust claim) against the estate. Whether that claim can produce an allowable loss, and at what value, is fact-specific and may not be clear until the administration moves on. If all you're left with is a debt the exchange owes you, the rule for debts (TCGA 1992 section 251) may mean no allowable loss at all.
  3. No crystallised loss yet. If the administration's still running and the tokens or claims keep some value, there may be no loss yet. Filing a loss claim before the facts support it is a risk in an HMRC enquiry.

So an exchange collapse isn't a simple write-off. The answer depends on the exchange, what you held there, how the administration's set up and how far it's got when you file. A guide written the week it collapsed can't tell you that, so check where things stand before you claim.

The step people forget: a capital loss must be CLAIMED to be usable

Even where a capital loss is clearly available, it won't reduce your tax on its own. You have to claim it, normally in your Self Assessment return.

HMRC's guidance on capital losses says you can claim up to four years after the end of the tax year in which you disposed of the asset. A negligible value claim runs on different rules. You can make it at any time while you still own the tokens, and the loss arises on the date of the claim or an earlier date allowed by TCGA 1992 section 24(2), which is the separate two-year limit, not the four-year one.

Here's what that means in practice:

  • If you sold rug-pulled tokens for pennies in the 2021/22 tax year (ending 5 April 2022), that loss had to be claimed by 5 April 2026, so the window's closed. If you didn't sell and still hold them, a negligible value claim is still open, but a claim made in 2026/27 lands the loss in 2024/25 at the earliest.
  • A loss on tokens you disposed of in the 2022/23 tax year (ending 5 April 2023), say ones sold off cheaply as an exchange wobbled, must normally be claimed by 5 April 2027.

If you lost money in the 2022 or 2023 crashes and haven't claimed, check which route you're on. A loss on something you sold has a four-year deadline. A negligible value claim doesn't, but every year you wait pushes the earliest date you can put on it later.

Carrying losses forward against future gains (why unreported loss years are recoverable value)

Once a capital loss is properly claimed, it doesn't expire. You carry it forward against future gains on anything, crypto, shares or other assets.

That's why unreported loss years matter. If you had a genuine capital loss on a disposal in 2022/23 and didn't claim it, the loss can still be recovered, but the claim has to reach HMRC by 5 April 2027, when the four-year window closes (TMA 1970 section 43). It's normally too late to amend a 2022/23 return, as that window shut on 31 January 2025, so the loss goes to HMRC as a separate claim in writing. Where the loss depends on a negligible value claim, check the separate two-year backdating limit first: a claim made now can't be backdated as far as 2022/23.

What a carried-forward loss is worth depends on your future gains. If you're still holding crypto and expect to realise gains, a loss from a token that collapsed in 2022 could offset tax at 18% or 24% on future disposals. For a gain of £20,000, a carried-forward loss of £5,000 saves between £900 and £1,200 in tax, depending on your income tax position.

Losses come off gains in the same tax year before anything is carried forward, and you can't skip a year to save them for a bigger one. Same-year losses come off first, even if that takes your gains below the £3,000 annual exempt amount and wastes part of it. Brought-forward losses work the other way: you only use enough of them to bring your gains down to £3,000, and the rest carries on.

Getting a defensible loss position

HMRC can open an enquiry into a return that claims a loss, and it's on you to prove it. A claim that stands up needs:

  • The correct characterisation of the situation (lost keys vs worthless asset vs exchange collapse).
  • Evidence that the asset was worthless on the date claimed, including market data, blockchain records, and project-status information.
  • The claim filed in the right tax year, within the four-year window (and, for a negligible value claim, the two-year backdating limit).
  • Consistency with the rest of your CGT return, including the correct s104 pool calculations for the affected tokens.

If you have unreported losses from collapsed exchanges, rug pulls or dead chains, the first step is to establish which tax year the loss arose in and whether the four-year window's still open. The CGT planning service covers loss identification and claim preparation for exactly these situations. Where an earlier year is involved and a Self Assessment return needs amending or filing late, the HMRC disclosure service handles the submission process.

Which of the three you're in decides whether there's a claim at all, so that's where we start: the facts first, then the claim.

Common questions

Can I claim a tax loss if I lost my crypto private keys?
Not just for losing them. Losing private keys isn't a disposal for Capital Gains Tax, because the key and the tokens still exist. But HMRC says that if you can show there's no prospect of recovering the key or accessing the tokens, a negligible value claim could be made. If HMRC accepts it, you're treated as disposing of and reacquiring the tokens, which crystallises the loss. See HMRC's Cryptoassets Manual at CRYPTO22400.
What is a negligible value claim for crypto?
It's a formal claim to HMRC that treats an asset you still hold as if you'd disposed of it and immediately reacquired it at the value stated in the claim (which can be nil). That crystallises an allowable capital loss without an actual sale. It applies where the tokens are worth next to nothing, for example a rug-pulled token or a dead chain, and, on HMRC's view, where lost keys mean there's no prospect of ever accessing them. The claim covers your whole section 104 pool of that token. It can be backdated to an earlier date if you owned the asset then and it was already of negligible value, but TCGA 1992 section 24(2) limits that earlier date to no more than two years before the start of the tax year in which the claim is made. See HMRC CRYPTO22500.
Can I claim a loss on a rug pull?
Possibly. If the token's become worth next to nothing (the project's collapsed, the contract's abandoned, there's no real market left), a negligible value claim under HMRC CRYPTO22500 may be available. You don't need to sell the token. Get advice on evidencing the claim properly.
Can I claim a tax loss on FTX or a collapsed exchange?
It's fact-specific and no deduction is guaranteed. Possible outcomes include a negligible value claim on the tokens held at the exchange, a capital loss on any legal claim against the exchange, or no crystallised loss yet if the administration's still going. Which applies depends on the facts, the status of the administration and HMRC's view at the time, so take professional advice before you file.
Is losing crypto a disposal for CGT?
No. Losing access to crypto, whether through a forgotten password, a lost hardware wallet or an inaccessible seed phrase, isn't a disposal. HMRC says so in CRYPTO22400. The asset stays in your s104 pool at its original cost. Only a sale, swap, gift or a formal negligible value claim triggers a CGT event.
How long do I have to claim a crypto loss?
Capital losses must normally be claimed within four years of the end of the tax year in which they arose. For example, a loss that arose in the 2022/23 tax year (ending 5 April 2023) must normally be claimed by 5 April 2027. It isn't automatic; you have to report the loss, and late claims may be refused. A negligible value claim is different: there's no deadline for making it while you still own the tokens, but the loss arises in the year of the claim or, at the earliest, two years before the start of that tax year.
Can I carry a crypto loss forward?
Yes. Once a capital loss is properly claimed, you can carry it forward indefinitely and set it against future capital gains. There's no time limit on using a loss once it's been validly reported. The catch is that it has to be claimed first, for the right tax year.

Need help with your crypto tax position?

Tell us about your situation and we will explain what is involved.

Step 1 of 2 · About you

Optional: a bit more detail (helps us prepare)